The first vertical farm showdown: Why you need to know what’s happening in Singapore

Conclusion

So here we have two very different models.  Sky Greens is as established as a company can hope to be in the vertical farm industry and is using a unique approach that has been at least successful enough to build 500 three-story high towers in less than two years.  On the other hand, we have Panasonic’s new venture that relies on older, more traditional greenhouse technology.

Basket garden_600x450_57bee757c3

Farm to market in 3 hours

There are positive and negative aspects to each model, but as competition for the local market presses these two companies against each other, those watching the vertical farming industry can hope to see even more cost effective innovation.  Who knows, maybe each will develop their own niche vegetable markets specialized to produce the leafy green most suited to their specific growing methodology?

Either way, Singapore is a unique environment and what happens here is important.

Singapore has the second densest population in the world, as ranked by the World Bank, and all the sustainability problems associated with that density.  Whereas fields and open space are almost always cheaper in land-rich countries like the United States, making vertical farming far from cost effective, “Singapore could be a special case, where land value is so exceptionally high, that you have no choice but to go vertically” says Gene Giacomelli, a plant scientist at the University of Arizona, who directs their the Controlled Environment Agriculture Center NPR reported.

Not only are the conditions right, but Singapore’s government is fully supportive of these ventures.  The government recognizes that food security and sustainability goals are so much easier to reach with local production.  Perishable, imported items like vegetables, which cannot be stored for long periods of time, are now grown with such proximity to the point of consumption  that shipping becomes almost a non-factor (3 hours in Sky Greens’ case).

One of the most important critiques of vertical farming is that the systems are not compatible with fundamental food supply crops like grain and rice.  While that is true, at least for now, for Singapore to just replace its perishable imports with local production will have an enormous impact on both its economy and its sustainability measures.

By seeing what works in a country that is so supportive and in need of vertical farming, others can replicate and build off of successful models instead of wasting time on what has already been shown to be less efficient.

We’ll be able to see if pushing new technologies like Sky Greens is the answer to the world’s hunger challenges (9 billion mouths to feed by 2050) or if we are already able to address them with tweaked versions of what we have like Panasonic.  In a future post, I’ll examine how these two models fit into different thinkers’ visions of the future of farming.

Plus, each of these farms are doing really cool and innovative things for agriculture!

33 thoughts on “The first vertical farm showdown: Why you need to know what’s happening in Singapore

  1. Pingback: What it means when big business listens | The Urban Vertical Project

  2. Pingback: Floating Responsive Agriculture | The Urban Vertical Project

  3. Pingback: Top 5 Required Readings For Vertical Farming | The Urban Vertical Project

  4. Pingback: Most mechanized vertical farm? | The Urban Vertical Project

  5. Pingback: Updates and Who I Am | The Urban Vertical Project

  6. Pingback: Vertical Farming in the Desert | The Urban Vertical Project

  7. Pingback: More info than you ever wanted to start your vertical farm | The Urban Vertical Project

  8. Pingback: The first vertical farm showdown: Why you need to know what’s happening in Singapore | The Sane Age

  9. Pingback: Virtual Vertical Farming (and we’re not talking about the internet of food) | The Urban Vertical Project

  10. Pingback: The Green Study on Break: The Blog Days of Summer | The Green Study

  11. Pingback: The first vertical farm showdown: Why you need to know what’s happening in Singapore | Neap|Tide Musings

  12. Pingback: Interview With Sky Greens Vertical Farmer Jack Ng | The Urban Vertical Project

  13. Pingback: How to convince your friends vertical farming is the next big thing – The Urban Vertical Project

  14. Nice research there!

    Iam interested to see the calculations. I keep wondering how this system can work without artificial lighting ?? Surely there should be a trade off on the growth rate

    • It is the same process/concept as any other greenhouse. Greenhouses don’t need artificial lighting. I don’t know of any literature for this project but am sure you could find some for light transmission through different glazed and unglazed surfaces.

  15. Pingback: One-time largest vertical farm shuts down | The Urban Vertical Farming Project

  16. Pingback: Why Vertical Farms Fail | The Urban Vertical Farming Project

  17. Pingback: Dubai's Emirates Airlines gets food from world's largest vertical farm | The Televisor

  18. Pingback: Dubai is getting the world’s largest vertical farm — and it will grow produce for the world’s largest international airport – The Coinage Times

  19. Pingback: Dubai is getting the world’s largest vertical farm — and it will grow produce for the world’s largest international airport – TechFeed

  20. Pingback: Dubai is getting the world’s largest vertical farm — and it will grow produce for the world’s largest international airport – runinroads.com

  21. Pingback: Dubai is getting the world’s largest vertical farm — and it will grow produce for the world’s largest international airport | Jack McCoy's Blog

  22. Pingback: Dubai is getting the world's largest vertical farm — and it will grow produce for the world's largest international airport - eduincode

  23. Pingback: Dubai is getting the world's largest vertical farm - and it will grow produce for the world's largest international airport

  24. Pingback: Dubai is getting the world's largest vertical farm — and it will grow produce for the world's largest international airport | Latest Free Investment Guides, Reports, Brochures & News

  25. Pingback: Dubai is getting the world's largest vertical farm — and it will grow produce for the world's largest international airport | Business Insider

  26. Pingback: Dubai is getting the world’s largest vertical farm — and it will grow produce for the world’s largest international airport |

  27. Pingback: Dubai Is Getting The World's Largest Vertical Farm — And It Will Grow Produce For The World's Largest International Airport | IAIUF

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s