Are Hydroponic Vegetables as Nutritious as Those Grown in Soil?

Our free vertical farming newsletter gets you access to lessons and stories from the industry not shared on the blog. So quick, sign up! Even before you start reading!

Are hydroponic vegetables as healthy as those grown in the soil? Someone asked the Times just that and they give a great answer, even citing opinions on traditional “organic, soil” advocates. In short, yes they are.

hydroponic lettuce

JASON HENRY FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

What the Times didn’t get into that is important to remember is that just as there are good and bad types of soil agriculture, there are good and bad types of hydroponic and vertical farming systems. Remembering that no type of farming is monolithic (here is a take down of a noisy vertical farming critic who seemed to miss that point) is essential here and there are studies that show both soil and hydroponic crops as the “healthier option.” It depends on, among other things like time spent in storage, how the particular type of farming is practiced.

I’ve also written about how vertical farming might even be able to make you a better healthier eater here.

But below is the piece as posted by the New York Times:

Question:

Are vegetables grown hydroponically as nutritious as those grown in soil?

Answer:

The bottom line is it depends on the nutrient solution the vegetables are grown in, but hydroponically grown vegetables can be just as nutritious as those grown in soil.

“Much as I think that soil is just great for growing plants, hydroponics has come a long way,” said Marion Nestle, a professor of nutrition, food studies and public health at New York University. “I’ve seen hydroponic producers who have tested their leafy greens for key nutrients, and the amounts fall well within normal limits for their crop and are sometimes even higher.”

Traditionally, plants obtain nutrients from soil. With hydroponics, the plants get nutrients from a solution instead. (Aeroponics, in which the plants’ roots are suspended in the air, is similar except fertilizer is misted onto the roots.) Usually inhabiting large warehouses or greenhouses, hydroponic plants are arranged indoors, often in tall shelves, and they rely on artificial light rather than sunlight.

Plants make their own vitamins, so vitamin levels tend to be similar whether a vegetable is grown hydroponically or in soil. It’s the mineral content that can vary in hydroponic crops, depending on the fertilizer used.

“You can enhance” a plant’s nutrient levels “simply by adding nutrients to the solution” they’re grown in, said Allen V. Barker, a professor at the Stockbridge School of Agriculture at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. “You could add whatever you wanted: calcium or magnesium, or minor elements like zinc or iron.” The result is that vegetables grown hydroponically could even be “nutritionally superior” to traditionally grown ones, he said.

Keep in mind that nutrient content varies for produce in general, regardless of the growing method. The differences relate to the type of fruit or vegetable, the time of year it is harvested, how long after harvesting the crop gets eaten, and how it is handled and stored from farm to fork.

Remember, too, that these differences in nutrient levels are unlikely to have a significant impact on overall health. The key message from most nutrition experts is simply the more vegetables you eat, the better.

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s